PayPal vs Western Union: Fees, Rates & Speed Compared
PayPal ahead nowhere; Western Union on GBP → EUR.
PayPal
Won 0 of 1 routes here
1.4Western Union
Won 1 of 1 routes here
4.3PayPal-to-PayPal payments and a Western Union remittance need different recipient arrangements. Decide whether the recipient wants to keep funds in a PayPal account, withdraw them to a bank or collect physical currency. The payment is not operationally complete merely because one balance has increased.
Live comparison: PayPal vs Western Union across popular corridors
Recipient payout route by route, PayPal against Western Union, from collected quotes (not guaranteed).
| Corridor | PayPal | Western Union | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| USD → INR($1,000) | — | ₹92,167.93 | N/A |
| GBP → EUR(£1,000) | €1,142.52 | €1,163.21 | Western Union (+€20.69) |
| USD → PHP($500) | — | ₱30,892.48 | N/A |
| USD → MXN($1,000) | — | MX$18,722.26 | N/A |
| GBP → PKR(£500) | — | ₨179,536.92 | N/A |
| USD → NGN($200) | — | ₦275,151.47 | N/A |
PayPal vs Western Union: Feature comparison
| Feature | PayPal | Western Union |
|---|---|---|
| Overall rating | 1.4/5 (Poor) | 4.3/5 (Excellent) |
| Fee structure | 5% with $0.99 min, $4.99 max | From $0 to $10+ depending on method |
| Exchange rate markup | 3% - 4% above mid-market | 1% - 4% above mid-market |
| Transfer speed | Instant to 3 days | Minutes to 5 days |
| Supported countries | 200+ | 200+ |
| Supported currencies | 25+ | 130+ |
| Max transfer | $60,000 | $50,000 |
| Delivery methods | PayPal Account, Bank Deposit | Bank Deposit, Cash Pickup, Mobile Wallet |
| Regulators | FinCEN, FCA, Various | FinCEN, FCA, Various |
A PayPal balance is different from collected cash
For a PayPal route, include any subsequent conversion or withdrawal needed for the intended expense. For Western Union, select the actual bank or collection option. Compare what is usable at the end of those paths, rather than a PayPal balance with an already-collected cash amount.
Fraud warnings and cancellation rules: PayPal versus Western Union
Both companies write a fraud warning into the contract itself, and the two read differently. PayPal's US user agreement lists scams it sees, among them the “Relative in Need”, where someone poses as a family member, often a grandchild, and claims an emergency. It tells users to send money only for themselves and not for others, and to confirm who the recipient is before completing a payment. Western Union's money transfer terms say its service is designed for sending to people you know and trust who are in the destination country named on the form, and that the Money Transfer Control Number (MTCN), the tracking number each transfer is given, should be shared with nobody except your receiver.
For Western Union those warnings are also a regulatory duty. In January 2017 it agreed to pay $586 million and admitted aiding and abetting wire fraud, the Federal Trade Commission says. The FTC order requires it to print clear fraud warnings on its paper and electronic forms, block transfers sent to anyone who is the subject of a fraud report, and refund a fraud-induced transfer whenever it failed to follow its own anti-fraud procedures.
Undoing a payment works differently too. PayPal's agreement allows a cancellation with a full refund only until your recipient has received the payment, from the transaction details or by calling customer service, and warns that once the payment is made you may not be able to cancel it. Western Union accepts a written cancellation request as long as the money has not been picked up or deposited by the time the request reaches it. Within 30 days of sending it returns the transfer amount and the fees; after that, the amount alone. A transfer that nobody collects or cancels within a year begins to carry a monthly administration charge, taken out of the amount sent.
PayPal vs Western Union: your questions
What does a Western Union cash receiver need to show at the counter?
Western Union's terms say the receiver should be ready to give their full name, an identification document, the sender's name, the MTCN and the approximate amount. In some countries the sender can add a test question, and the receiver then needs its answer. Western Union does not verify the receiver's address and may pay out when the name on the ID differs from the one you entered in minor ways, though it is not obliged to. If it judges the information insufficient, it refuses to pay and the money becomes available to refund to you.
Can my receiver take a Western Union transfer in a different way from the one I chose?
In some countries, yes. Western Union's terms say a receiver may be offered a payout method or payout currency other than the one the sender selected, and that by sending you authorise Western Union to honour the receiver's choice. A switch of currency can count as a separate transaction, on which Western Union says it may make additional money from the conversion. A PayPal personal payment goes to the recipient's PayPal account instead, and for sending abroad PayPal's help centre says you can send money to friends and family internationally using PayPal or Xoom.
Which Western Union company handles a transfer sent from the US?
Western Union's terms say Western Union Financial Services, Inc. provides transfers within the US and its territories. For money sent outside the US, it provides the service jointly with Western Union International Services, LLC, which handles the non-US portion. Both hold money transmitter licences from New York's Department of Financial Services, and their NMLS numbers are 906983 and 906985. The terms treat every transfer as its own agreement, covering only that payment, so sending once does not oblige Western Union to accept a later transfer under the same contract.